Bad News was Good News, Good News was Bad News...Now What ?


Something happened last week in capital markets that might suggest a significant shift with investors thinking.

The market sold off despite some very strong economic news all week—until Friday.

market selloff in december 2013

Consumer credit expanded by 18.2 billion in October, which was the largest increase in 5 months. Revolving credit expanded by 4.3 billion, which was the largest increase since May. [ii] The US consumer is certainly feeling confident enough to take on more debt on their credit cards.

consumer credit expansion in 2013

The US economy expanded at a much faster pace in the 3rd quarter than originally anticipated. Q3 GDP grew at a 3.6% annualized pace. Businesses certainly are anticipating a strong consumer as they added inventory to the tune of 1.7 percentage points or almost half of GDP growth. [iii]

real gdp percent change by quarter

New home sales recovered from a precipitous drop this summer, adding 444,000 homes in October. [iv]

drop in home sales

Consumption grew at a reasonable pace and the consumer was willing to spend down their savings to make purchases. Again, this is showing us that the consumer is gaining confidence in the recovery. [v]

growth of consumption over 2013

personal savings rate over time

The tepid movement in the market prior to Friday, despite the good economic news, might have been because of concern that good news would mean that the Fed starts tapering their bond purchases—which have fueled much of the recovery.

Yet, something happened on Friday. The jobs report was released adding to all the positive releases throughout the week. The US economy added 203,000 jobs, almost all coming from the private sector. [vi] The market reaction was quite the opposite with a very strong rally of 198.69 points on the Dow. [vii]

My take is participants might be growing comfortable with the eventual Fed taper not leading to an immediate spike in rates. Or, investors may now believe that the economic recovery is strong enough to sustain itself without the stimulus that the Fed has been providing. If you look at 10 year Treasury rates, they barely budged all week. They rose by 10bps during the week and were at a standstill on Friday. [viii]


10 year yields by day during december 2013

If my assessment proves correct, the equity markets could launch much higher and not pose a significant threat to bond holdings for now. Be aware that bonds could drop in price as actual rates begin to rise and that might be some time in the distant future.

The real test of economic resilience should be reflected in wages. Wages are simply not growing and it's hard for an economy that is roughly 70% dependent on consumption to sustain itself without real wage growth. You can see over the past five years that growth in real compensation per hour has moved a little around the edges, but the trend is basically flat. [ix]

real compensation per hour over time

Slight sifts in allocation may be necessary, but it's difficult to find things that are undervalued at this time within the US. We continue to find opportunities overseas in developed and emerging international markets.

If you have questions or comments, please let us know as we always appreciate your feedback. You can get in touch with us via Twitter, Facebook, or you can email me directly. For additional information on this, please visit our website.

Tim Phillips, CEO – Phillips & Company

Alex Cook, Investment Analyst – Phillips & Company

[i] Google Finance
[ii] “United States: Consumer Credit (G19)”, Moody’s Analytics
[iii] “United States: GDP (Second Estimate)”, Moody’s Analytics
[iv] Federal Reserve Economic Data
[v] Ibid.
[vi] “Economic Calendar”, Bloomberg
[vii] Bloomberg
[viii] MarketWatch
[ix] Federal Reserve Economic Data